Engineering visit to the
Ivchenko Progress machine building design bureau in the Ukraine.
Formerly the Ivchenko Lotarev
development design beuro or Opytnoe Konstructorskoe Byuro-478 (OKB-478)
During the Soviet era OKBs
were closed and sealed institutions working on the design and development
of advanced technology. As a result the facilities that remain in
existence today are totally self contained. Although these days
facilities are moving around and expanding within the countries
concerned to make better use of labour, and materials etc, the main
sites still stand alone and isolated. Each beauru has its own accommodation
for the workers (thousands and thousands of them) and their families,
their own hospitals, welfare system, public transport system, water
treatment system, power generation, reservoirs ets. As a result
the places are of a size beyond imagination. Quite literally raw
and innocuous raw material goes in through the (OKB) rail system,
and engines (or whatever the produce) comes out. During the "good
ol days" nothing or very little actually came out at all.
Some of the better known
OKBs include: OKB-45 (Mikulin, engines), OKB-26 (Kilmov, engines),
OKB-155 (Mikoyan, aircraft, interceptors in particular), OKB-938
(Kamov, rotary wing)
.jpg)
Having such an interest
in eastern engines, history and culture this visit was a real treat
for me. I was there to propose some design alterations to a gas
turbine (hopefully their Ivchenko AL-20) that would increase engine
efficiency in its role as a packaged power plant in gas compression,
power generation etc.
.jpg)
Sitting with the Director
of the company (previously the Soviet design beauro head) was for
my interest in these engines and OKBs like sitting with a member
of the royal family. I try to imagine all of the correspondence
that has moved over that desk in the last thirty years. Some very
interesting items I am sure.
.jpg)
Following the discussion
a team of fourteen aerodynamisists, metallurgists and so on poured
over the ideas. Over the course of an hour they came up with six
workable solutions, alterations to my initial ideas (so they would
actually work) and how to alter their engine design to incorporate
them. It was no small task either as it involved lengthening the
engine by nearly three feet and altering the orientation of the
gas path totally. These were not just rough solutions they arrived
at either. They were proper, signed off proposals to progress.....WOW!
Imagine going to a western engine manufacturer and saying "please
do this to your engine, you have an hour and a bit to decide if
it is possible and come up with a solution" I bet they would
not have the manpower in place to even start.
.jpg)
On the last day of the
visit I was presented by the head of the design bearu a pair of
FULL SCALE sectional general arrangement drawings of both of the
original engine and one incorporating the modifications at over
4 meters in length......They had actually started drawing it by
the time I left.....I was awe struck at the efficiency and the retention
of old knowledge. Some of these guys were in their seventies but
were jealously retained by the company for their experience. By
this time they had actually been given their accommodation free
of charge for the reminder of their lives along with full support
for the family. The company retains the knowledge close at hand
and the families never have to worry about their pension stretching
to an extra shopping trip when the kids visit...
.jpg)
On returning home I marveled
at the difference between UK industry today and in the past, computers
and graduates rule the day, all of the experience has been made
redundant or retired and left wholly un appreciated. I had just
returned from a trip where a gas turbine had been totally re designed
in an hour or so by the people who first drew it out thirty years
ago, and here I was back in the UK unable to find someone who could
frame a 4m long picture... A very sincere shame indeed.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)